Haven't driven a 718. One year and about 5500 miles on (either three other cars and a busy schedule) I love my 981S. The 3.4L six is plenty torquey for my needs and sounds better than ever. If I had to replace, I would stay eith a cayman or boxster S. Just make sure you get the transmission, color and options that are important to you.
Apples and oranges to my e46 m3, to any 1er I've driven and by extension to any 2er as well. Those are all great cars but no comparable.
|