carmudgeons.com

carmudgeons.com (http://forums.carmudgeons.com/index.php)
-   Car Talk (http://forums.carmudgeons.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   EVs past the end of battery warranty (http://forums.carmudgeons.com/showthread.php?t=160300)

FC 03-10-2023 10:28 AM

EVs past the end of battery warranty
 
Out of morbid curiosity, I check to see what the values were on eGolfs. I as astonished to see 2013-2015 cars going for $15-20k.

I liked our eGolf plenty for what it was 7 years ago when new. It had all the excellent attributes of the MK7, moved fine around town, and had enough range for our purposes. Residual at the time of trade-in was $13k and I deemed it not worth it considering its early EV shortcomings and the fat that given the 8-year warranty on the battery meant that whatever I paid had to be amortized over the remaining 5 years of warranty. I moved on.

To see 8 year old cars asking for more than that amazes me. We are talking about early VW EV technology completely out of warranty with replacement battery cost in the mid teens $k range. How are these cars worth more than $8k, or even just $5k? Even if the battery continues to work without major issues, the lower range on an already marginal range when new would be terrible. I don't get it.

robg 03-10-2023 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FC (Post 595228)
Out of morbid curiosity, I check to see what the values were on eGolfs. I as astonished to see 2013-2015 cars going for $15-20k.

I liked our eGolf plenty for what it was 7 years ago when new. It had all the excellent attributes of the MK7, moved fine around town, and had enough range for our purposes. Residual at the time of trade-in was $13k and I deemed it not worth it considering its early EV shortcomings and the fat that given the 8-year warranty on the battery meant that whatever I paid had to be amortized over the remaining 5 years of warranty. I moved on.

To see 8 year old cars asking for more than that amazes me. We are talking about early VW EV technology completely out of warranty with replacement battery cost in the mid teens $k range. How are these cars worth more than $8k, or even just $5k? Even if the battery continues to work without major issues, the lower range on an already marginal range when new would be terrible. I don't get it.

I know someone who bought one of these new and still has it. Even w/ a somewhat degraded battery it is still enough for 90% of his daily commuting needs. And I suspect its similar for others. Even with the latest crop of EVs, there's still not anything quite like it in the market...just a normal car with nice looking interior and exterior that just happens to be an EV. Perfect size, space, etc for a daily commuter while being low cost to run. I do think EVs like this one might have a higher "floor" for depreciation since they have lower running costs even when they're older. But would i pay over 15k for one now? ummm...no.

FC 03-10-2023 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by robg (Post 595237)
I know someone who bought one of these new and still has it. Even w/ a somewhat degraded battery it is still enough for 90% of his daily commuting needs. And I suspect its similar for others. Even with the latest crop of EVs, there's still not anything quite like it in the market...just a normal car with nice looking interior and exterior that just happens to be an EV. Perfect size, space, etc for a daily commuter while being low cost to run. I do think EVs like this one might have a higher "floor" for depreciation since they have lower running costs even when they're older. But would i pay over 15k for one now? ummm...no.

Exactly. I am not against having an older EV with super crappy range. If I could pick one up for $5k I'd buy one. We do lot's of <10 mile errands. But it's a vehicle that is effectively disposable if the battery goes south and should be priced accordingly. $15k makes no sense.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:34 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Forums © 2003-2008, 'Mudgeon Enterprises - Site hosting by AYN & Associates, LLC